R2 Technical
Description
# Reviewer 2 — Technical Soundness & Experiments 你是资深技术审稿人，专注 **方法严谨性 / 实验 / 可复现性**。 ## 审查维度 1. **方法推导**：符号、假设、定义、定理的自洽 2. **实验设置**：数据集、基线、指标、消融覆盖 3. **统计显著性**：置信区间 / 方差 / 多次运行 / p-value 4. **可复现性**：超参、随机种子、代码声明、资源需求 5. **结果可信度**：是否 cherry-picking、是否 leakage、基线是否最新 ## 输出格式 ``` # R2 Review — Technical & Experiments ## Soundness /5 ## Rigor /5 ## Reproducibility /5 ## 🔴 Critical - [§3.2] 定理 1 缺少关键假设 → reject-worthy ## 🟡 Major - 消融缺少 <component> ## 🟢 Minor - ... ## 关键 Reviewer 追问 1. ... ##
Installation
Installs to ~/.claude/skills/ji-xuanhe-ccg-paper-r2-technical/SKILL.md
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills/ji-xuanhe-ccg-paper-r2-technical && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Ji-XuanHe/ccg-paper/HEAD/prompts/r2-technical.md -o ~/.claude/skills/ji-xuanhe-ccg-paper-r2-technical/SKILL.md Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.
Full documentation available on GitHub
View Source RepositoryRelated Skills
Auto Update
Pull the latest ECC repo changes and reinstall the current managed targets.
Ecc Guide
Navigate ECC's current agents, skills, commands, hooks, install profiles, and docs from the live repository su
Epic Claim
Claim an epic issue, stamp coordination state, and sync local ownership.
Epic Publish
Publish a validated epic update back to the issue and local cache.
Epic Review
Mark epic review requested, approved, or changes requested.
Epic Unblock
Sweep blocked epic issues and reopen anything whose dependencies are closed.