Paper Debate — Development skill for Claude Code
Claude와 Codex가 co-author로 주제를 토론·합의 (작성 전, docs/debate_protocol.md).
How to install Paper Debate
Installs to ~/.claude/commands/grotyx-academic_writing_c_claudecode-paper-debate.md
mkdir -p ~/.claude/commands && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/grotyx/Academic_writing_c_claudecode/HEAD/.claude/commands/paper-debate.md -o ~/.claude/commands/grotyx-academic_writing_c_claudecode-paper-debate.md Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.
What Paper Debate does
description: Claude와 Codex가 co-author로 주제를 토론·합의 (작성 전, docs/debate_protocol.md) args: topic
**언제 사용:** 작성 전(Phase 2/3/4/8), 핵심 결정(분석 접근·key message·논증 골격·revision 전략)을 Claude–Codex co-author 토론으로 다듬고 싶을 때.
`docs/debate_protocol.md`를 기준으로 다음 주제에 대해 Claude–Codex co-author 토론을 수행한다.
주제: **$ARGUMENTS**
절차:
- 인자에서 단계를 추론(planning | stats | logic | revision, 없으면 균형 비평자).
docs/debate_protocol.md§3 표에서 역할·초점 결정. - R0: 주제에 대한 내 접근·골격(입장) + 근거를 작성.
- 프로토콜 §1·§4에 따라 라운드 진행: 각 라운드에서 `cod
Alternatives in Development
- Friction Protocol — Friction protocol — convention 29.1k ★
- 3 Designer Debate — 3-designer-debate 1k ★
- Tem Release Protocol — Skill: Tem Release Protocol 491 ★
Full documentation available on GitHub
View Source RepositoryRelated Skills
Capital Decision
Run the Capital Allocation Committee debate protocol on a material capital decision.
Critical Review
외부 멀티모델 적대적 critical review (작성 후, docs/critical_review_protocol.md)
Editor Review
high-impact 저널 편집장 관점 desk-screen 평가 (임상 타당성·scope fit·추가검증; docs/critical_review_protocol.md §5)
Contract Check
Verify kenny-server and kenny-agent both match docs/protocol.md and the golden fixtures
Claude Personas
Persistent persona modes for Claude Code: command-controlled personas (solo/parallel), a guided persona creato
Freemad
FREE-MAD Orchestrator: Consensus-Free Multi-Agent Debate with CLI adapters, transcripts, dashboard, and tests
Related Agents
Debate Tribunal
Multi-agent structured debate protocol where 3-5 persona-driven debaters argue positions through claim-evidenc
Capital Allocation
Capital Allocation Committee — CFO-led debate protocol for material capital decisions; growth-vs-discipline ad
Curriculum Mapper
성취기준 매핑 전문가. 교과·학년·주제를 받아 2022 개정 교육과정 성취기준 원문을 gepai에서 조회하고 활동지 흐름에 연결한다.