grotyx

Editor Review — Development skill for Claude Code

Development community

high-impact 저널 편집장 관점 desk-screen 평가 (임상 타당성·scope fit·추가검증; docs/critical_review_protocol.md §5).

How to install Editor Review

Installs to ~/.claude/commands/grotyx-academic_writing_c_claudecode-editor-review.md

Terminal

mkdir -p ~/.claude/commands && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/grotyx/Academic_writing_c_claudecode/HEAD/.claude/commands/editor-review.md -o ~/.claude/commands/grotyx-academic_writing_c_claudecode-editor-review.md

Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.

What Editor Review does

description: high-impact 저널 편집장 관점 desk-screen 평가 (임상 타당성·scope fit·추가검증; docs/critical_review_protocol.md §5) args: target

**언제 사용:** 작성 후(Phase 6 QC). 기계적 QC를 넘어, **이 논문이 임상적으로 타당한가 / 논문 분야의 high-impact 저널 scope에 맞는가 / 무엇을 추가해야 경쟁력이 생기는가 / 안 되면 어느 하위 저널이 현실적인가**를 편집장·임상 관점에서 평가하고 싶을 때. `/critical-review`(reviewer 적대 검토)의 자매 — 이건 **editor desk-screen(상위 tier 기준)**.

대상: **$ARGUMENTS** (생략 시 전체 원고)

평가 기준은 `scripts/critical_prompts/editor.txt`(정본 프롬프트, `--role editor`)와 `docs/critical_r

Alternatives in Development

Triage PRs — Classify all open PRs by module, review state, scope, and architectural impact — produces a prioritized triage 12.6k ★
Akb Production Review — Review AKB production-governance docs and hooks 156 ★
Clawdmeter Plus — A round AMOLED desk display for your live Claude Code usage, weather, background-agent health, and a daily voi 87 ★