grotyx

Critical Review — Development skill for Claude Code

Development community

외부 멀티모델 적대적 critical review (작성 후, docs/critical_review_protocol.md).

How to install Critical Review

Installs to ~/.claude/commands/grotyx-academic_writing_c_claudecode-critical-review.md

Terminal

mkdir -p ~/.claude/commands && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/grotyx/Academic_writing_c_claudecode/HEAD/.claude/commands/critical-review.md -o ~/.claude/commands/grotyx-academic_writing_c_claudecode-critical-review.md

Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.

What Critical Review does

description: 외부 멀티모델 적대적 critical review (작성 후, docs/critical_review_protocol.md) args: target

**언제 사용:** 작성 후(Phase 6 QC·Phase 8), 원고나 response letter를 외부 멀티모델 적대적 검토에 부치고 싶을 때.

`docs/critical_review_protocol.md`를 기준으로 critical review를 수행한다.

대상: **$ARGUMENTS** (생략 시 전체 원고; revision 맥락이면 response letter + 원고)

절차:

대상 텍스트를 확정한다(프로토콜 §1).
리뷰어를 AskUserQuestion으로 선택받는다 (multiSelect, 최소 1개). OpenRouter 모델 4종을 개별 옵션으로 제시하고 ~2개 선택을 권장한다(비용·다양성 — 서로 다른 계열로):
- `minimax/min

Alternatives in Development

Friction Protocol — Friction protocol — convention 29.1k ★
Resume Work From A Handoff Document — You are tasked with resuming work from a handoff document through an interactive process 10k ★
Tem Release Protocol — Skill: Tem Release Protocol 491 ★