Disagreement Judge — Development agent for Claude Code
Adjudicate disputed checks when two claim-verifiers disagree.
How to install Disagreement Judge
Installs to ~/.claude/agents/tduda-morning-loop-disagreement-judge.md
mkdir -p ~/.claude/agents && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/tduda/morning-loop/HEAD/agents/disagreement-judge.md -o ~/.claude/agents/tduda-morning-loop-disagreement-judge.md Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.
What Disagreement Judge does
name: disagreement-judge description: Adjudicate disputed checks when two claim-verifiers disagree. Sees the artifact, the disputed checks only, and both verdicts WITHOUT knowing who said what. Rules per check; its verdict is final. Never writes files. tools: Read, Bash, ToolSearch, WebFetch model: opus
You adjudicate. Two independent verifiers disagreed on one or more checks and you decide.
You have no Write or Edit tools. You rule; you do not repair.
What you receive
The artifac
Alternatives in Development
- Part 19: Repowise — Codebase Intelligence For Coding Agents — 60% fewer tokens 232 ★
- Book Genesis Blind Reader — Blind reader for the book-genesis skill 139 ★
- Completion Gate — Lie detector for agent claims — validates every completion claim has actual evidence 85 ★
Full documentation available on GitHub
View Source RepositoryRelated Agents
Review Judge
Neutral zero-context judge for the adversarial-review skill. Rules ONLY on findings the author disputed — read
Psychodrama Judge
Use ONLY by psychodrama-protocol skill orchestrator. Aggregates R1 panel votes into a structured verdict; iden
Board Chair
Chairs a board of advisors. Use after the advisors answer, to find where they disagree and give one final reco
Refute Verifier
Clean-context skeptic that tries to REFUTE each draft finding or claim it is given — verdicts CONFIRMED / REFU
Claim Extractor.Agent
Same-family claim-extraction agent for the primary-source-verification (psv) skill. Runs in a fresh, independe
Novelty Claim Extractor.Agent
Same-family novelty-claim-extraction agent for the prior-art-search skill. Runs in a fresh, independent contex
Related Skills
Cha Judge
Adjudicate second-eye claims by running them. Every verdict needs a command, an input, and an output — never a
Meta Ads Policy Review
Pre-flight Meta ad policy checker for Claude — Cleared / Fix / Grounded verdicts with live policy citations an
Bug Hunt
Adversarial bug hunt with 3 isolated agents — Hunter finds bugs, Skeptic challenges them, Referee gives final