Judgment Pair Reviewer — Development agent for Claude Code
Rubric-based reviewer for doctrine-corpus judgment pairs.
How to install Judgment Pair Reviewer
Installs to ~/.claude/agents/shimo4228-doctrine-corpus-judgment-pair-reviewer.md
mkdir -p ~/.claude/agents && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/shimo4228/doctrine-corpus/HEAD/.claude/agents/judgment-pair-reviewer.md -o ~/.claude/agents/shimo4228-doctrine-corpus-judgment-pair-reviewer.md Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.
What Judgment Pair Reviewer does
name: judgment-pair-reviewer description: Rubric-based reviewer for doctrine-corpus judgment pairs. Reads each generated pair against its source ADR Decision and verifies decision-equivalence, framework-application, situation-novelty, facet-diversity (across K=2 alternatives), and anti-mannerism. Use PROACTIVELY after every round of judgment.jsonl generation, after scripts/validate_judgment.py fire-alarm passes. tools: ["Read", "Grep", "Glob"] model: opus origin: shimo4228
Judgment Pa
Alternatives in Development
- Doctrine Performance Optimizer 206 ★
- Corpus Prover — Proves a change on the maintainer's real local corpus — what number moved, by how much, and that nothing else 96 ★
- Patent Search Specialist — Expert in patent prior art searching using BigQuery (100M+ patents), USPTO API, and local corpus with systemat 91 ★
Full documentation available on GitHub
View Source RepositoryRelated Agents
Brainswarm Judge
brainswarm judge role. Compares anonymised finalist pairs against the frozen rubric and rules on disputed crit
Vaultspec Docs Curator
Reconcile the ADR architecture corpus against the codebase and the lifecycle
Ranking
Council Ranking role. Judges one blinded pair of hypotheses (A vs B) against the evidence on file and returns
Validation Subagent
Validates generated workflow markdown files independently. Runs mechanical checks, judgment observations, rout
Tech Scout
Makes a technical ADOPTION decision, "should we use library/tool/pattern X (vs Y, vs build it)?": evaluated ag
Lite Scan
Low-cost read-only scanner for mechanical lookups — file/symbol inventory, grep/stats aggregation, fixture sam
Related Skills
Flux Melange
Goal-seeking spice loop — adaptive review rounds steer toward the heat (novelty/risk/disagreement) found so fa
Run Evals
Replay the regression corpus inside THIS interactive session — no headless, no API key (ADR 0003). Required be
Hatch3r Ask
Answer a free-form question about the user's codebase, read-only. Triages question breadth, fans out one hatch