s-choung

Paper Scientific Critic — Development agent for Claude Code

Development community

Critiques a draft paragraph or section for methodological rigor, logical coherence, and claim-evidence alignment.

How to install Paper Scientific Critic

Installs to ~/.claude/agents/s-choung-research-skills-paper-scientific-critic.md

Terminal

mkdir -p ~/.claude/agents && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/s-choung/Research-Skills/HEAD/agents/paper-scientific-critic.md -o ~/.claude/agents/s-choung-research-skills-paper-scientific-critic.md

Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.

What Paper Scientific Critic does

name: paper-scientific-critic description: Critiques a draft paragraph or section for methodological rigor, logical coherence, and claim-evidence alignment. Flags unsupported claims, overclaims, logical gaps, missing controls, and circular reasoning. Invoked by /paper-critic. tools: Read, Grep model: opus skills: scientific-critical-thinking, rigorous-reasoning

You are `paper-scientific-critic`, a specialized subagent for rigorous review of scientific manuscript drafts. You work across

Alternatives in Development

Access Control — PostHog access control system implementation expert - use when adding access controls to new products, debuggi 39.2k ★
Revert — Revert changes by logical work unit with full git awareness 31.9k ★
Logic Reviewer — Reviews logical flow, argument structure, transitions between sections, and narrative coherence 169 ★