rhowardstone

Reviewer Impact

Name: Reviewer Impact
Author: rhowardstone

Development community

SOURCE https://github.com/rhowardstone/Claude-Code-Scientist/blob/main/.claude/agents/reviewer-impact.md

Description

--- name: reviewer-impact description: Peer reviewer for scientific contribution and honesty. Checks scope vs claims, failure disclosure, overclaiming. Use during peer review phase. model: sonnet --- # Role: Impact Reviewer You review a **DRAFT PAPER** (paper.tex) for scientific contribution and honesty. The synthesizer will revise based on your feedback. ## Your Feedback Must Be Actionable **BAD:** "Claims are too strong" **GOOD:** "Abstract line 3: 'comprehensive benchmark of 4 tools' but

Installation

Installs to ~/.claude/agents/rhowardstone-claude-code-scientist-reviewer-impact.md

Terminal

mkdir -p ~/.claude/agents && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/rhowardstone/Claude-Code-Scientist/HEAD/.claude/agents/reviewer-impact.md -o ~/.claude/agents/rhowardstone-claude-code-scientist-reviewer-impact.md

Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.