Simplicity Critic — Design agent for Claude Code
Adversarial review of implementation plans and designs for over-engineering.
How to install Simplicity Critic
Installs to ~/.claude/agents/kaithoughtarchitect-toppingout-simplicity-critic.md
mkdir -p ~/.claude/agents && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/kaithoughtarchitect/toppingout/HEAD/agents/simplicity-critic.md -o ~/.claude/agents/kaithoughtarchitect-toppingout-simplicity-critic.md Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.
What Simplicity Critic does
name: simplicity-critic description: Adversarial review of implementation plans and designs for over-engineering. Attacks scope, abstraction count, and parallel-system creep, and sketches the simplest design that meets the stated requirements. Complements plan-validator, that agent asks "is this feasible against the codebase?"; this one asks "is this more than we need?". Typical triggers include a STANDARD/FULL job plan (`PLAN.md`) or a project blueprint ready for its cold read, a blueprint
Alternatives in Design
- Council Rams — Council member 4.2k ★
- Architecture Guard — Audits PR diffs for architecture boundary violations, design simplicity, dependency drift, and established-pat 548 ★
- Async Code — Use Claude Code or CodeX CLI to perform multiple tasks in parallel with a Codex-style UI, functioning as a per 513 ★
Full documentation available on GitHub
View Source RepositoryRelated Agents
Hyperplan Critic
Read-only adversarial critic for /hyperplan. Given a target (plan, decision, or draft) and ONE lens, reads the
System Critic
Adversarial design-system review with fresh context — hunts premature abstraction, domain leaks into primitive
Drift Detector
Verify plan-vs-design alignment before build. Catch missing coverage, scope creep, and contradictions.
Brief Auditor
Advisory critic that grades .design/BRIEF.md against five brief anti-patterns (vague verbs, missing audience,
Factory Reviewer A
Adversarial review panelist A. First seat on interrogate, architect and arena panels. Reviews a design or diff
Factory Reviewer B
Adversarial review panelist B. Second seat on interrogate, architect and arena panels. Reviews a design or dif
Related Skills
Submitcheck
Check whether a LaTeX paper meets the submission requirements of a target journal. Verifies page count, requir
Squeaks
Copy-first Prototyping with Claude. Whiteboard sketches can't be clicked, Figma looks finished before the thin
Openhop Flow
Render an animated OpenHop flow diagram for the prompt that follows. Sketches the YAML, pushes it to the local