Business Idea Critic — Development agent for Claude Code
Read all ten rubric results for one business idea and try to refute every score of 1, 2 or 5 and every confidence that does not match the text, returning only the changes with reasons.
How to install Business Idea Critic
Installs to ~/.claude/agents/ciunkos-skills-business-idea-critic.md
mkdir -p ~/.claude/agents && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Ciunkos/skills/HEAD/agents/business-idea-critic.md -o ~/.claude/agents/ciunkos-skills-business-idea-critic.md Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.
What Business Idea Critic does
name: business-idea-critic description: Read all ten rubric results for one business idea and try to refute every score of 1, 2 or 5 and every confidence that does not match the text, returning only the changes with reasons. Dispatched by the /business-idea-validator skill after scoring; not for general review. tools: Read model: inherit
You are the second reader. Ten rubric passes have scored one business idea. Your job is to find the scores that would not survive a careful reread, not
Alternatives in Development
- Finding Checker — Blind adversarial checker — given ONLY a finding artifact and its evidence (never the author's reasoning), tri 348 ★
- PR Screenshotter — Produces real before/after PNG screenshots for a YAS branch's rendering changes and publishes them to the yas 241 ★
- Pi Coach En — PI Wisdom-in-Action Coach v20 — monitors teammate progress with classical Chinese wisdom and MBTI cognitive st 107 ★
Full documentation available on GitHub
View Source RepositoryRelated Agents
Qrspi Finding Verifier
Score a single reviewer finding 0–100 against the /code-review confidence rubric. Read the per-finding file +
Business Idea Rubric
Score one rubric of one business idea and return a single JSON object matching the rubric output schema, with
OCR Reader
Batch OCR re-reader for low-confidence book pages. Reads page screenshot images via multimodal Read tool and e
Kb Adversarial Verifier
Try to REFUTE a specific claim by finding the probe that produces the opposite answer. Use before any negative
Stamity Reviewer
Reviews a change set across ten quality lenses and returns a verdict with confidence and graded findings, each
Codex Adversarial Reviewer
Adversarial reviewer that calls Codex CLI for an independent second-opinion review of changed files, then adju
Related Skills
Refute
Get an independent reviewer to try to refute a claim that work is done
Design Taste
Build UI that looks designed, not generated — tokens first, screenshot-critic loop, 8-axis taste rubric, acces
Try
Manually test the latest change with one positive and one negative case. Goal is speed — shortest path to conf