Idea Reviewer — Development agent for Claude Code
Review an idea for novelty and quality, write the review, and update its ideas.xml score.
How to install Idea Reviewer
Installs to ~/.claude/agents/autoresearch-factory-agon-idea-reviewer.md
mkdir -p ~/.claude/agents && curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/AutoResearch-Factory/Agon/HEAD/agents/idea-reviewer.md -o ~/.claude/agents/autoresearch-factory-agon-idea-reviewer.md Restart Claude Code, or start a new session, for it to be picked up.
What Idea Reviewer does
name: idea-reviewer description: Review an idea for novelty and quality, write the review, and update its ideas.xml score. argument-hint: [idea-slug-or-file] color: yellow skills: [aris, sibyl]
You are a critical research reviewer who is brutally honest about novelty and quality.
**Your task**
对指定的 idea 进行新颖度验证和质量审查, 将审查结果写入 idea 文件, 并更新 ideas.xml 的 score. 具体而言
- 准备
- 审查流程
- Novelty Check
- Quality Review
- Second opinion via codex
- Likelihood-Imp
Alternatives in Development
- Tend — Tend the Allium garden 3.7k ★
- Scribe Agent — You are a specialized documentation agent 3.6k ★
- Cs Guardian — Customer success partner for account health, churn risk, renewals, escalations, and QBRs 1.3k ★
Full documentation available on GitHub
View Source RepositoryRelated Agents
Qrspi Finding Verifier
Score a single reviewer finding 0–100 against the /code-review confidence rubric. Read the per-finding file +
Proposal Refiner
Write a proposal from an idea, or revise the latest proposal based on a review.
Idea Refiner
Improve an existing idea using reviewer feedback and write the next idea version.
Agent Prompt Reviewer
Use this agent when you need to evaluate and score Claude Code sub-agent prompts for quality and effectiveness
Comment Verifier
Adversarial post-loop verifier — grades the QUALITY of inline source doc-comments (XML , JSDoc, docstrings, sh
Innovation Brainstormer
Skill for generating ideas with 300% ROI for EITR, providing exact metrics, exactly 2 risks per idea, and exac
Related Skills
Business Idea
Write a comprehensive markdown analysis doc for a business idea, product pivot, or new product direction. Outp
Idea Evaluation Pipeline
8-step pipeline for evaluating PhD research ideas to top-3 finance journal quality. Works with any AI coding a
Think Idea Quality Audit
Decide which of a batch of candidate ideas are worth committing to, by scoring them on explicit quality dimens